Law enforcement authorities in Pennsylvania have opened an investigation into the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention following a complaint filed by relatives of Jewish jurist Raphael Lemkin and the European Jewish Association. But will the institute change its unauthorized name ?
Earlier this year, law enforcement authorities in Pennsylvania have opened an investigation into the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention and Human Security following a formal legal complaint filed by relatives of Jewish jurist Raphael Lemkin and the European Jewish Association (EJA).
Joseph Lemkin, an American attorney and relative of Raphael Lemkin, the Polish-born Jewish lawyer who coined the term “genocide” and helped draft the Genocide Convention after World War II, has joined the association, chaired by Rabbi Menachem Margolin, in challenging the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention over its use of the family name and its charitable fundraising.
The legal campaign contends that the Institute draws credibility from Raphael Lemkin while advancing positions, including accusations against Israel, that the relatives pursuing the complaint believe misrepresent his legacy.
The Institute disputes those allegations and says other Lemkin relatives support its work.
Raphael Lemkin, who lost almpost 50 members of his family in the Holocaust, introduced the term genocide in 1944. Born in 1900 in what is now Belarus, he was deeply influenced by early accounts of mass atrocities, particularly the Armenian genocide and later the Nazi persecution and mass murder of European Jews. Horrified by the systematic destruction of entire groups, he coined the term “genocide” in 1944, merging the Greek genos (race) with the Latin cide (killing). He subsequently became a driving force behind the adoption of the 1948 Genocide Convention. He died in New York in 1959.
The Convention defines genocide through specified acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. Establishing that intent is central to the legal assessment. Today, the term is misued to characterize Israel’s defensive war against Hamas in Gaza which followed the massacre con 0ctober 7, 2023, the largest murder of Jews since the Holocaust.
For Joseph Lemkin, the dispute also has a personal dimension.“This is my family’s name, and they took it without asking,” he said in a June statement about the campaign. “His name is not a brand to be borrowed,” he added.
Deleted Kennedy post highlights dispute over Raphael Lemkin’s name and legacy
Earlier this month, a since-deleted post by US Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. rejecting genocide accusations against Israel, has provided a new backdrop to the campaign challenging the use by the Pennsylvania institute of the name and legacy of Raphael Lemking.
The post had received approximately 336,000 views before it was removed.
In the October 7 post, preserved in a screenshot circulated by UN Watch executive director Hillel Neuer, Kennedy described the genocide accusation against Israel as “laughable on its face” and argued that it provides an “effective permission structure for antisemitism.”
Neuer shared the screenshot while asking whether Kennedy had genuinely published the statement. The post was also reported by PJ Media. The reason for its subsequent deletion has not been established.
Kennedy was responding to a post highlighting an open letter published by the Jewish Institute for National Security of America on the third anniversary of the Hamas-led attacks on Israel. Its signatories, retired senior military leaders and legal experts, rejected allegations that Israel committed genocide in Gaza.
They argued that civilian casualties, however devastating, do not by themselves establish genocidal intent and cited Israeli military precautions and assistance to civilians in support of their assessment.
Neither Kennedy’s statement nor the letter addressed the Lemkin Institute directly. But their interventions touch on a central argument advanced by Joseph Lemkin and the Brussels-based European Jewish Association: that the term genocide carries legal and historical responsibilities that must withstand political pressure.
The campaign had delivered 100 letters to state and federal officials seeking scrutiny of the Institute’s use of the name lEMKIN and its fundraising. Recipients included Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, Attorney General Dave Sunday, lawmakers, such as Senator John Fetterman, and federal authorities.
The campaign requested an investigation and remedies including a compulsory name change, with further action if warranted by the facts. It also reported that a complaint was pending before the Pennsylvania Department of State at that time.
“They took the name of the man who gave the world the word ‘genocide,’ and they are using it to raise money,” Rabbi Margolin stated.
The Institute offered a different accoun. It said its name honours Lemkin’s scholarship, rejected allegations that it supports terrorist organizations and characterized the campaign as an attempt to suppress its genocide-prevention advocacy.
It also said Joseph Lemkin does not speak for the entire family or officially represent a Lemkin estate, and cited support from Peter Lemkin. The organization said it had expressed openness to discussing a name change while requesting clarification of the legal basis for the demands.
The broader debate over Gaza remains contested. Amnesty International and a UN Commission of Inquiry have concluded that Israel committed genocide, allegations Israel rejects. Such assessments, like the military professionals’ rejection of the charge, must be distinguished from a judicial determination.
The campaign over the Lemkin name raises a separate question: whether the Institute’s public presentation and fundraising accurately convey its relationship to the historic figure whose name it invokes.
Kennedy’s deleted post has added political attention to the debate over genocide terminology. Joseph Lemkin and the European Jewish Association are asking authorities to examine the institutional questions behind their complaint.
For them, the dispute concerns the public trust attached to a name that helped shape international law. For the Institute, it concerns its freedom to conduct work it believes honours Lemkin’s scholarship. The task for authorities is to assess the specific legal claims on their evidence.
Neither Governor Shapiro’s office nor the Pennsylvania Attorney General or the bureau that oversees charities, answered a question by the European Jewish Press whether an action had been taken in response to the complaint and what are the next steps. For its part, the Lemkin Institute didn’t say whether it would consider a name change.
